There's nothing better than cutting into a steak with a deep, golden-brown crust and a juicy centre. But getting that crust right isn't just about turning the heat up and hoping for the best. It's about preparing the surface properly, using the right fat, getting your cooking surface hot enough and knowing how to handle the steak while it cooks.
Whether you're using a cast-iron pan in the kitchen or firing up the BBQ outside, a few simple changes can make a massive difference to the result.
This is the method I use to build a better crust, including why I flip my steak every 30 seconds, when a steak weight comes in handy, and how to get the best results from a pan or BBQ.
Why Does a Good Steak Crust Matter?
That browned exterior isn't just there to look good. It's where you develop a huge amount of the steak's roasted, savoury flavour.
When the surface of the meat gets hot and dry enough, browning reactions create the deep colour and complex flavours we associate with a properly seared steak. The challenge is getting that crust to develop without overcooking the inside.
Too much moisture on the surface can slow browning, while an unsuitable cooking fat or a pan that hasn't heated properly can make it harder to get the result you're after.
The goal is simple: a well-browned exterior, a centre cooked to your preference, and enough control over the process that you can repeat the result.
Step 1: Pat the Steak Dry
Before you do anything else, take your steak and pat it dry with paper towel.
This is one of the easiest ways to improve your sear, and it's a step I wouldn't skip. Surface moisture needs to evaporate before the meat can brown effectively. If your steak is wet, more of the available heat goes into evaporating that moisture instead of developing the crust.
Make sure you dry both sides, as well as the edges where practical.
You don't need to press the paper towel into the meat or squeeze it. Just remove the moisture sitting on the surface.
Step 2: Lightly Oil the Steak and Add Salt
Once the steak is dry, add a small amount of olive oil and rub it over the surface until the coating looks thin and slightly opaque. Then apply your salt evenly.
The idea is to use a light coating, not to leave the steak dripping with oil. You want an even layer across the meat, with enough seasoning to complement the flavour of the beef.
You can use sea salt or your preferred seasoning, depending on the result you're after. If you're using a flavoured rub, remember that it may already contain salt, so adjust your additional seasoning accordingly.
For steak, I want the seasoning to complement the meat rather than completely overpower it.
Step 3: Get Your Pan Seriously Hot
If you're cooking in a pan, don't rush straight into putting the steak on a lukewarm surface.
Use a heavy pan that retains heat well. Cast iron and carbon steel are good options, as is suitable stainless steel cookware. Preheat it properly before the steak goes in.
A hot, heat-retentive pan helps maintain contact with the steak and develop the browned crust you're looking for. If the pan temperature drops too much when you add the meat, the sear can take longer and you may struggle to get the colour you want before the centre overcooks.
Make sure your kitchen is ventilated, particularly when cooking over high heat.
Step 4: Choose the Right Fat for Searing
Once the pan is hot, add a small amount of suitable high-temperature cooking fat.
A few options worth considering are:
-
Beef tallow: A natural choice when you want to bring a beefy flavour to the cook.
-
Avocado oil: A useful option when you want a relatively neutral oil suited to high-heat cooking.
-
Ghee: Clarified butter, with most of the milk solids removed, making it suitable for higher-heat cooking than ordinary butter.
Choose a fat appropriate for the temperature you're cooking at. Smoke points vary between products, so don't assume every version of a particular oil or fat behaves identically.
I wouldn't use a huge amount. You want enough to help the steak make good contact with the pan, not a pan full of oil.
You can also use beef tallow to finish the steak's flavour profile. If you enjoy cooking with tallow, it's worth experimenting with the difference it makes compared with a more neutral cooking oil.
Step 5: Use a Steak Weight to Improve Contact
Here's a technique that can make a real difference when you're searing steak in a flat pan or on a solid BBQ hotplate: use a steak weight.
The reason is contact. If your steak curls or has an uneven surface, parts of it may not sit flat against the cooking surface. That can leave you with patches that are deeply browned and other areas that haven't developed much colour.
A suitable, heatproof steak weight can help keep more of the steak in contact with the hot surface, encouraging a more even sear.
Place it on the steak carefully and use enough pressure to improve contact without aggressively squeezing the meat.
This technique is most useful on a flat pan or solid hotplate. A weight won't provide the same benefit across open BBQ grill grates, where the meat is only contacting the grate bars.
Don't have a steak weight? You can still get a great crust without one. Drying the surface and maintaining the right heat are more important than buying another piece of equipment.
Step 6: Flip Your Steak Every 30 Seconds
Forget the idea that you absolutely must cook one side of a steak for several minutes before flipping it just once.
For this method, I flip the steak approximately every 30 seconds while building the crust.
Frequent flipping can help develop browning on both sides while giving you better control over how quickly the centre cooks. It also helps distribute the heat rather than leaving one side exposed to the pan for an extended period.
Here's how I'd approach it:
-
Place your steak onto the hot cooking surface.
-
Allow it to sear for approximately 30 seconds.
-
Flip it over and cook the other side for another 30 seconds.
-
Continue flipping at roughly 30-second intervals while monitoring the crust and the internal temperature.
-
Adjust the heat if the outside is getting too dark before the centre is cooked to your liking.
The 30-second interval is a starting point, not a rigid rule. A thin steak, a thick ribeye and a pan that loses heat quickly will all behave differently.
You don't need to keep pressing the steak down, either. Use the weight to maintain contact where needed, rather than constantly squeezing the meat.
How to Get a Better Crust on the BBQ
The same basic principles apply outside, but cooking on a BBQ introduces a few differences.
You have to manage the heat across the cooking surface, deal with flare-ups from dripping fat and consider how the thickness of your steak affects the way it cooks.
1. Preheat the BBQ properly
Get your BBQ hot before the steak goes on. A properly preheated cooking surface helps develop a crust rather than slowly warming the exterior.
Clean the grill grates before cooking. If you're using a solid hotplate, make sure it's clean and ready for high-heat searing.
2. Dry, oil and season the steak
Use the same preparation method as you would for a pan-seared steak: pat it dry, apply a thin coating of olive oil and season it.
Avoid leaving excess oil on the surface, as dripping fat can cause flare-ups on the BBQ.
3. Sear over direct heat
Place the steak over the hottest part of the BBQ and begin developing the crust.
If you're using grill grates, the contact points will create the sear marks. If you're cooking on a flat hotplate, you'll generally have a larger area of contact with the surface.
For a hotplate, you can use a suitable steak weight to help maintain contact. On conventional grill grates, focus instead on getting the steak positioned correctly and managing the heat.
4. Flip frequently and manage flare-ups
Try flipping the steak approximately every 30 seconds as you build the crust. Keep an eye on the surface colour and move the steak if the heat is too aggressive or flames start licking around the meat.
You want browning, not a burnt exterior.
5. Finish thick steaks over indirect heat if needed
A thin steak may cook through while you're building its crust over direct heat. A thick steak is a different story.
If you have a thick ribeye, porterhouse or another substantial cut, you may need to develop the crust over direct heat and then move the steak to a cooler zone to finish cooking more gently.
That way, you can keep building colour without excessively charring the outside while waiting for the centre to reach your preferred doneness.
Use a meat thermometer rather than relying on cooking time alone. Steak thickness, starting temperature and BBQ heat all affect how quickly the centre cooks.
Common Mistakes That Prevent a Good Crust
Putting a wet steak straight into the pan
Excess surface moisture slows browning. Pat your steak dry before adding oil and seasoning.
Using too much oil
You don't need the steak swimming in fat. A light coating of oil on the meat and a small amount of suitable cooking fat in the pan are generally enough.
Cooking in a pan that isn't hot enough
If your cooking surface isn't properly preheated, the steak can take longer to brown. Give the pan or hotplate time to heat up before cooking.
Using a fat that can't handle the temperature
Different oils and fats behave differently under high heat. Choose one suitable for your cooking temperature and replace it if it starts smoking excessively.
Turning the heat up without paying attention
High heat is useful for searing, but there's a point where the outside can burn before the centre reaches the desired doneness. Adjust the heat or move the steak to a cooler zone when necessary.
Pressing too hard on the steak
A steak weight can help improve contact, especially on a flat cooking surface. But aggressively squeezing the meat isn't necessary. Use the weight to improve contact rather than flattening the steak.
Ignoring the thickness of the steak
A thin steak and a thick steak need different approaches. The crust may develop quickly on a thin cut, while a thick steak may need a direct sear followed by gentler cooking.
Should You Rest Your Steak After Searing?
Once your steak has reached your preferred doneness, remove it from the heat and allow it to rest briefly before slicing.
The appropriate resting time depends on the thickness of the steak. A thinner cut may need very little time, while a thick steak generally benefits from a longer rest.
Don't leave the steak sitting for so long that the crust loses the texture you've worked to develop. If you rest it on a plate, avoid covering it tightly, as trapped steam can soften the exterior.
When it's ready, slice and serve it while the crust is still at its best.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the secret to getting a good crust on steak?
Start with a dry surface, season properly, use a hot cooking surface and choose a suitable cooking fat. Managing heat and avoiding excess moisture are key to developing a well-browned exterior.
Should you oil the steak or the pan?
For this method, I lightly coat the steak with olive oil before seasoning it, then add a small amount of suitable high-temperature cooking fat to the hot pan. Avoid using excessive amounts of either.
Is beef tallow good for searing steak?
Yes, beef tallow can be a useful option for searing steak, provided it's properly rendered and suitable for the cooking temperature. Its flavour also pairs naturally with beef.
Should you flip steak every 30 seconds?
Frequent flipping is a useful technique for building an evenly browned crust and helping control the cook. Around 30 seconds is a practical starting point, but adjust the timing for the thickness of the steak and the heat of your cooking surface.
Can you get a good steak crust on a BBQ?
Absolutely. Preheat the BBQ properly, dry the steak, season it and sear over direct heat. For thick steaks, you can finish over indirect heat once the exterior has developed the colour you're after.
Does a steak weight make a difference?
A steak weight can help improve contact between the meat and a flat cooking surface, particularly when the steak is uneven or curling. It isn't essential, though, and it won't provide the same benefit on open grill grates.
Ready to Cook a Better Steak?
Getting a great crust doesn't need to be complicated. Dry the surface, season the meat, get your cooking surface hot and choose the right fat for the job.
Whether you're using a cast-iron pan at home or cooking over the BBQ, pay attention to contact, heat and the thickness of your steak. Flip regularly, monitor the centre and don't let the outside burn while you're chasing colour.
And if you want to experiment with your seasoning, try a rub that complements beef without overpowering it.
Explore the BBQ LAB range to find a seasoning profile for your next steak.
0 comments